Discussion Forum

Is there any proof that Socrates was even a real person?

Besides Plato’s works? I mean, what if Plato made up Socrates just to use as a kind of mouth piece to explain his own beliefs and ideas? Is that not plausible? Socrates could merely be a fictional character.
It’s not as if Plato would have no reason for doing so. He could use the character of Socrates so that he wouldn’t be persecuted himself for his beliefs. I’m not saying that this is probable, I’m merely asking the question, to see if it is possible.

16 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
HeWhoWatchesAshley Kemball-CookguruArwenLindy Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
HeWhoWatches
Guest
HeWhoWatches

I’m inclined to believe Plato made him up. It is a device he used fairly often it seems.

Ashley Kemball-Cook
Guest
Ashley Kemball-Cook

This isn’t a stupid question at all. There is split between experts in his field as to whether Socrates did exist in Plato’s dialogues. The base facts are that, Socrates did exist and Plato probably studied under him. But Plato may have made up Socrates as literary technique in his dialogues. Many writers of that time used Socrates (sokratikoi logic) from the 390s, so Plato may have just been conforming to this literary technique. The general consensus is that, although Socrates did exist Plato placed him in scenes in order to conduct a dialogue and provoke a philosophical discussion. If… Read more »

guru
Guest
guru

It only takes a few minutes to see the politics of the current era and see how this could be the case. We have urban myths and legends. Just because these myths are repeated and believed by some does not make them true. Writers (and even historians) can be found to blend fact and fiction in weaving a more exciting tale. We can also look, as you did, to the motivation of the person who is recording events for history. I commend you on your critical thinking. Not accepting being spoon-fed is a rarity. In today’s era, we don’t have… Read more »

Arwen
Guest
Arwen

What if so???

Lindy
Guest
Lindy

Research is good for the soul. I recommend it highly.

Alex
Guest
Alex

Xenophon, a greek historian wrote about him, but you never know, maybe they were all made up too, and they call themselves historians to make us believe, what they don’t know is that we too are made up…LOL

http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/cgi-bin/ptext?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0212&query=head%3D%231

Good luck!

PS. Pardon my dark sense of humor!0!

virtrava
Guest
virtrava

Marco is right. But nevertheless a good q. Try to prove it by reading what others said about him and judge whether they were talking about a real or an invented person. For that matter was Shakespeare a real person?

amerye950
Guest
amerye950

He was a well known person af his time, even lampooned in a contemporary play, ” The Clouds” by Aristophanes. I never heard this idea that he wasn’t a real person — what’s your problem w/ him?

sab's
Guest
sab's

you are plausibly joking, right?

vrindaganguly
Guest
vrindaganguly

Well,no proof to me..i think similar isto you??

G
Guest
G

plato’s ideas differ from socrates — i guess you could say plato in an attempt to make himself a genius created a teacher for himself named socrates — they were very ethos centered and what your credentials were said a lot obout you. politicians like to use ethos a lot — (“i am not gay” — larry craig while standing next to his wife in big dark sunglasses).

Neptune2bsure
Guest
Neptune2bsure

Its a possibility many writers have two or three pen names, Mark Twain for example.

You would have to do a lot of research to know for sure did you look it up research on the Internet? You sound wise and intuitive this is a sign of high intelligence congratulations, keep drumming up the facts of why you believe this to be so, research to see if anyone else thinks so, outside of your study group and so on. Good luck. Very interesting question.

Marco4
Guest
Marco4

That is possible, but not probable. Plato is not the only source of knowledge of Socrates, the “philosopher, soldier” Xenophane gave accounts of Socrates as did the play write Aristophanes.

Plato, Xenophane and Aristophanes each had different views on what type of person Socrates was, it is doubt full that Socrates was an imaginary figure.

buttermilk
Guest
buttermilk

Socrates was not a real person. There was another man using the name Socrates at the time. (Don’t take this answer seriously!)

Skydol
Guest
Skydol

either way i dont think hes coming back

Jay
Guest
Jay

If socrates is a fictional character im sorry but George Washington is not real neither is Hilter