- March 16, 2011 at 5:37 am#34262
So this is for my religion class.. I don’t know too much between the two religion.
How would you criticize Buddhism from the perspective of Judaism? How might someone practicing Judaism criticize Buddhism by arguing that Buddhism is not a religion?
Answer by Doc
The swastika would be a good start
- March 16, 2011 at 6:06 am #266096
- March 16, 2011 at 6:50 am #266095
We never have, and never will tell someone their religion is wrong. To all the people who think we dislike religions because they are different, you know nothing about Judaism, yet you still feel as though you are allowed to judge us, and make assumptions that are not true. I am sorry for my harsh language, but I am tired of so many people thinking we are like that.
- March 16, 2011 at 7:22 am #266094
- March 16, 2011 at 7:26 am #266093
- March 16, 2011 at 7:35 am #266092
- March 16, 2011 at 7:53 am #266091
- March 16, 2011 at 8:50 am #266090
I don’t know a lot about Buddhism, but let me give you the foundation of Judaism.
Judaism is the belief in one god…. Jesus and the holy spirit have no correlation with Judaism, not at all. He was not acknowledged in the Tanakh and is imaginary to most of us, you know like how Christians view Hindu gods. We follow the Tanakh (5 books of Moses and the Torah) and this is a very long book, on a side note the OT is not the Jewish book that is a mistranslated abridged Christian version of the Tanakh.
I could go on and on, but I don’t feel like it.
- March 16, 2011 at 9:42 am #266088
Buddhism doesn’t have to be criticized. It should be respected- it’s a religion that advocates inner peace and kindness towards others.
Someone from the Judaism belief might be against Buddhism simply because of differing views on what ‘God’ is, but that’s all I can think of. Unless, of course a person is closed-minded. That depends on the individual.
- March 16, 2011 at 10:37 am #266086
These two religions might seems similar at first glance, but they actually have their differences. A major difference is that Judaism believes in one god, where as buddhism have their respect etc etc towards the Buddha, who gave them all wisdom to ‘redeem’ themselves from suffering (which is somewhat similar to judaism)
- March 16, 2011 at 11:06 am #266084
I don’t want to make the Jews mad or the Buddhists but will only say a few things.
Either of them could become atheistic because they are both lacking in truth so very much and this leads to thinking God must not exist at all. What they need is to find Jesus as their Messiah and to trust in him completely.
Now, the difference is the Buddhists believe in Buddha and they are considered idol worshipers but they will tell you they are not.
Whereas the Jews say they are looking for their Messiah but he already came and they didn’t recognize him. Instead they rejected him. And they will also say this is not true, but if they would read the New Testament which tells all about it, they would find the truth.
- March 16, 2011 at 11:45 am #266081
- March 16, 2011 at 12:37 pm #266080
If they start arguing among one another, I would suggest that the Buddhist is not a real Buddhist and the one practicing Judaism is not doing so well.
You might say to the teacher that a good religion does not end up with criticism. If he are she is a good teacher, they will have to agree with you. More on a genuine side of a religion is on my biography.
- March 16, 2011 at 1:29 pm #266079
In true Buddhist teaching, the closer answer would be something like:
Since the buddhist belief is that all is one, then there is no difference betwen these two belief systems at all. Or more specifically, when it comes to spiritual pathways to the divine, “All rivers ultimately run into the same ocean.”
thanks for your question
- March 16, 2011 at 2:24 pm #266077
Many think that both religions are good, though each was interpreted and taught uniquely to different regions in ancient time.
Good religious disciples don’t criticize the teaching because the teaching is sacred, but can criticize the rituals and the routines that people do.
Many scandals become publicly known in the Western churches: from bishops, pastors, and fathers. The scandals including greed and child molestation have tarnished the reputation of the churches. The damage to the foundation of the belief is far greater. It affects the church followers greatly because the tainted preachers delivered bad energy to the church goers. The routine formality and rituals become a social event where people gather not for essence of the faith: seriously studying the Bible, uplifting the moral character, … etc.
On the other hands, many westerners have little idea of what authentic Buddhist belief is about. Some westerners think that Buddhist belief is a philosophy. People in the Western faith often remain ignorant about the Buddhist belief partially due to the Bible’s protectionism teaching. Many Buddhist monks have stayed in low profile and remained mostly isolated in the monasteries or temples. The behavior of the and the famous Dalai Lama also reflects very well in the public.
The recent killing of the Tibetan monks by the Chinese Communist regime also has demonstrated peacefulness of the monks, despite years of persecution. Another notable group is the Falun Gong practitioners. For the past nine years, the Falun Gong followers has been severely persecuted by the Chinese Communist regime. One of worst offensive human right violations is the organ harvesting against live sedated prisoners, who practice Falun Gong, an ancient spiritual meditation exercise. Today, Falun Gong practitioners continue to protest in peace to stop further persecution.
Recent comeback of the Buddhist belief in India has taken place. Many Hindi converted to Buddhism. Falun Gong has spread into churches and schools. Portion of the Falun Gong scripture becomes standard in new school textbooks. Students are learning Falun Gong meditation and movements exercises is PE classes.
- March 16, 2011 at 3:15 pm #266075
There’s a whole book on it ‘Letters to a Buddhist Jew’ by Rabbi Akiva Tatz.
Buddhism seeks the concept of enlightenment via meditation and other forms of inner searching. Judaism understands that Buddhism is a ‘purely spiritual’ practice.
Judaism, however, uses the physical to attain spirituality, for example, by saying blessings before and after eating, by enjoying a physical relationship within the bounds of marriage and other laws, by enjoying wine but ensuring it is kosher, i.e. Judaism believes that in order to obtain lasting spirituality, it is necessary to experience and enjoy physicality.
I would argue that Buddhism is not a religion as it doesn’t appear to have a God or gods, just a pursuit of enlightenment as a goal.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.