Discussion Forum

Do you believe that stones and vegetables have a consciousness?

“Nature taken in its abstract sense, cannot be ‘unconscious’, as it is the emanation from, and thus an aspect (on the manifested plane) of the Absolute consciousness. Where is that daring man who would presume to deny to vegetation and even to minerals a consciousness of their own? All he can say is, that this consciousness is beyond his comprehension.” H.P.Blavatsky

23 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
1 Comment authors
ManoGodal∞kemyMD0William MMel Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
ManoGod
Guest
ManoGod

There are three levels or kingdoms in the physical realm.

The plant kingdom. This has growth life but not soul (breath) life or spirit life. Therefore it does not have consciousness because that is in the breath life category.

The animal kingdom. This has growth life and breath life but not spirit life.

Kingdom of Man. This has growth life and breath life. It had spirit life until adam fell, but Christ died to make that spirit life available to all who choose to accept it.

al∞kemy
Guest
al∞kemy

If it is true that part of who you are is your what you are aware of, then these objects are part of you by your consciousness of them. But what is left for the unconscious, what is left for ignorance.

MD0
Guest
MD0

rocks don’t have sentience.

William M
Guest
William M

No, otherwise they’d be screaming themselves to death when I ate them.

Mel
Guest
Mel

well shoot, I allready don’t eat meat… now I can’t eat minerals or vegitables? what’s left for me?

🙁

lolololol

Sandra
Guest
Sandra

I have considered this question many times, as it does seem bewildering if you do not understand the concept of the construction of living and non-living things. Vegetation contain cells and tissues only. Consciousness comes from the make up of a brain, which is an organ of the body. The most intricate organ of the body other than the heart. Since plant life does not develop beyond the simple tissue needed for photosynthesis to take place, no organs are developed within the plant itself. Cells make tissues that make muscles and organs. Since a plant has a simple cellular composition… Read more »

testpattern(raster effect)
Guest
testpattern(raster effect)

Yes and they have souls, which is why they can be saved.

DM
Guest
DM

Consciousness implies a certain amount of awareness and responsiveness to outside stimuli. Stones are not living organisms, so they cannot be conscious. Plants are alive, but they have no real awareness, so they aren’t conscious either. Some plants seem to be aware of their surroundings (like sunflowers turning towards the sun, or venus fly traps eating flies), but those are reflexes and not conscious reactions.

This is also why a person can be ‘unconscious’. People have a consciousness, but in certain states (sleep, coma, knocked out, etc) that consciousness is effectively ‘switched off’.

Smug Alert
Guest
Smug Alert

I do not believe that they are possessed of an ego, the kind, or level of consciousness I have. If I am going to prune a fruit tree, for instance, I ask it’s permission beforehand. To me it’s a simple courtesy. If I am going to move a stone in the garden, I do not ask it’s opinion, but I remain mindful of the fact, nonetheless, that it too resonates with an energy, a life, as I do. I don’t anthropomorphise Nature, but I do try to be respectful of it, a good neighbour, if not a good citizen of… Read more »

Littlemswright
Guest
Littlemswright

Gee – Who said “with gods help anything is possible”

If people can believe in god – why can’t they believe this?

jethom33545
Guest
jethom33545

That daring man is right here.No,stones and vegetation don’t have a consciousness.

daniil the cavejew
Guest
daniil the cavejew

No. According to psychology, consciousness is being aware that you exist. Since even the majority of animals don’t know they exist (they can’t recognize themselves in a mirror), it is safe to say a rock isn’t self-aware either.

Bimonics
Guest
Bimonics

No, it takes a soul man.

Gluon
Guest
Gluon

Ha ha… now that’s just precious… and no…LOL

Mystic Mantra
Guest
Mystic Mantra

My dear friend, allow it to happen to you
dont be affraid, you know enough to let it be
let it be and you will get all the answers,

seek your own path, in that manner you will own your own truths
there will be people guiding you, cause I know its just around the corner for you, dont prolong it further,
know what im talking about ?

END OF JOY! YOU ARE ALL GAY MEN!
Guest
END OF JOY! YOU ARE ALL GAY MEN!

No, that is dumb!

Obsidian 74
Guest
Obsidian 74

H.P.B. is a crazy woman who makes assertions without evidence.

No, they don’t have a consciousness. There is no universal consciousness. Stones aren’t even alive. Vegetables are living, but do not have a brain nor a consciousness.

Get real, guys. Stop living in a fairy tale.

shewok
Guest
shewok

No. And unless stones and vegetables can demonstrate consciousness, I won’t ever believe it.

Smoking Frog
Guest
Smoking Frog

sure. so does my right toe-nail

Pixiechick
Guest
Pixiechick

Naturally, of course